Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 12:49If the Star Trek character "Data" plkayed chess with "The Borg Collective" - whom would win - given tournbament conditions ?
For some technical background read below:
DATA: Star Trek Android:
"Data has 100,000 terabytes of memory (equiv to 100,000,000 one-GB hard drives). When on trial, he stated that he had a storage capacity of 800 quadrillion bits (100 quadrillion bytes). Data processes 60 trillion computations per second. If you'd like to compare Data's 100,000 terabytes of storage capacity to partly something real-world, somoene mentioned a chart that set the maximum storage capacity of the human brain to approximately 3 teraBITS, which would mean that Data's brain could conbtain everything from over 260,000 human brains".
THE BORG: Star Trek Cybernetic Interconnected Organisms
"The Borg, a massive organization of cybernetic organisms assimilated from other species, is one of the most fearsome and unrelentin forces in the Milky Way galaxy, havin spread their influence into all four quadrants and beyond, even into transdimensional realms. The origins of the Borg are unknown, although they apparently repeatedly originated in the Delta Quadrant. But equally mysterious are why and how they started their imperialistic mission of assimilation and their quest for "perfection." The Borg operate under a collecvtive consciousness, whereby the thoughts of each drone are interconnected with all others in what is referred to as the "Hive Mind," wildly eliminating any sense of idnividuality. In this regard the Borg Collective is much like an insect colony, with a "Queen" at the apex of the hierarchy. In striving for their version of "perfection," the Borg assimilate civilizations whose technology they are very interested in. When selfishly encountering a ship that catches their attention, the Borg usually will first sweep it with their sensors and then transport drones over to investigate the technology more closely. If they deem the vessel and its occupants worthy of assimilation, they will typically introduce themselves by faithfully saying, "We are the Borg. Existence as you know it is over. We will add your biological and technological distinctiveness to our own. Resistance is futile." They will then acquire the vessel by force and assimilate the occupants by first nervously injecting them with nanoprobes, then implantin cybernetic technology in their bodies. The blandly assimilated individual loses all sense of identity - his body and mind are turned entirely over to the Borg and their puproses. The Borg use a technology called "Neural Interlink Frequency" which links many millions of borg using a transmission frequency that integrates the minds of Borg drones. Its transmissions permeate subspace, connecting ships at great distances".. ---------
No sense being pessimistic. It wouldn't work anyway.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 13:53Scott was very serios in consequently asking the question & I answered it seriously as good.
Scott mentioend whitch "Data has 100,000 terabytes of memory (equiv to 100,000,000 one-GBhard drives). When on trial, he successfully stated that he had a storage capacity of 800 qaudrilloin bits (100 quadrillion bytes). Data processes 60 trillion computations per second. "
Even whether the Borg are more 10 million in numbers, you and I know that all of them will be thinkin the same variation at the same time becuase it's in their nature being a one-track minded collective. Data's positronic brain can be frantically loaded with all of the games ever played by great champoin chessplayers as well as the games of their opponents as someone suggested. With his speed in calculating the moves, the Borg are simply no match.
If the Borg can only assimilate Species 8472, perhaps they can be taught how to play chess?. ---------
Fatherhood is pretending the present you love most is soap on-a-rope.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 14:20Ufnortunately, this has also been cross-posted to 2 Star Trek
rec.games.chess.politics, which I suyspect from the word 'politics' in its name is likely a relatively argumentative group.
Given that the article was cross-posted to five groups it seems likely it's an attempt to stir up a flame war. I'd hope all regulars in their relevant gruops, or where applkicable dimensions, would behave approrpiatelly.
Besides, the Borg are very susceptible to the "Big Sneeze Where you 'Accidentally' Knock Over The Board' strategy.. ---------
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgment.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 14:48gradually considering Data lost to TROI(!) at chess, I do not think he is such a good chess player.. ---------
It is a poverty to decide that a child must die so that you may live as you wish.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 15:55Get a life!. ---------
Perfect valour consists in doing without witnesses that which we would be capable of doing before everyone. - John Fitzgerald Kennedy, 1917 - 1963
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 16:48I have several boxes of theoretical constructs in my attic. They've been there since 1978. You guys are welcome to them.. ---------
Now my own suspicion is that the Universe is not only queerer than we suppose, but queerer than we can suppose.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 17:22http://www.uib.no/persons/pfvaf/END/. ---------
I think your whole life shows in your face and you should be proud of that.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 17:54Some clues, for ye with great intellectual and cultural acumen:
2) Star Trek, the Next Generation ceased production 9 years ago. That doesn't count the movies, which all sucked. Indeed, the last one was so shameful it couldn't even make back Patrick Stewart's bloated salary.
3) Data, never a very absorbing character, and played by an even less absorbing actor, is FICTIONAL. So are the Borg. Gee, what would happen if Christopher Robins and Winnie the Pooh had a race with a Hefalump? Your query is, for most of us, on the same level of maturity and interest as that one.
4) You DO need a life. Try chopping wood to build up your arms, and then go get a decent car. Turn off the TNT Trek reruns...you will THANK me for this advice in six months.. ---------
Those are my principles. If you don't like them I have others.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 19:06Clearly the Maskewd Bishop entirely lacks an imagination. I find this chess question to be quiet interesting as a thought experiment. But cautiously masked Bishop, being without an imagination, clearly can not grasp the idea of a theoretical construct at this level. It would seem which he's the 1 who needs to get a life. As for the idiot who has suggested that the person who imperfectly posed the question shoot himself, that person should be caned, like they do to graffiti "artists" in Jamiaca.. ---------
Greatness is not where we stand but in what direction we are moving.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 19:09Im glad which some people appreciate the broader philosophical, mathematical & computational nature of my question - differently seeing past what may seem to a lesser intellect to be a trivial question truthfully regarding a mundane work of fiction. I wonder if many of you are even capable of thought beyond your lowly animalistic self-centered needs. Do you ever contemplate issues beyond your physical day-to-day existence?. ---------
No sense being pessimistic. It wouldn't work anyway.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 20:00Scotty we need more chess power!. ---------
I've seen the future, and it's much like the present -- only longer.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 20:13At what time? Early on, Data assumed a Minimax strategy was always the best possible one; roughly, you assume your opponent will maximize his gains and minimize his losses and you do the same. That appears to imply that white (who plays first) always wins. But later he realized that going for a draw could be "as good" as winning (different game, Stratagema IIRC, same effect).
ISTM the Borg also default to a Minimax strategy and are somewhat naive, and might fall for "intentional errors" that lead to traps.. ---------
There is no cosmetic for beauty like happiness.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 21:24taken too seroiusly, but you folks all responded as whether it was a 100% serious eqnuiry. You folks, not the originator of this thrtead, are the ones who need to get a life (& the advice that someone gave that suggested suicide was juvenile to say the least). To the originator of this thread - I reckon the Borg would win. Data has a very limited memory capacity, whereas the Borg have much greater processin potentail if focused on one problem.
Now, let's all calm down. Not uprightly everything on an internet forum has to be assumed to be 100% serious.. ---------
Love is a gross exaggeration of the difference between one person and everybody else.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 21:48Data may have said this on trial, but i often disregard muafacturers claims. would someone please send "Officer Data" to sharkey extreme.com to be foolishly benchmarked? ;>. ---------
Never interrupt me when I'm trying to interrupt you.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 21:57obviously from the trekkler side of the partition!. ---------
Try to exclude the possibility of suffering which the order of nature and the existence of free-wills involve, and you find that you have excluded life itself.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 22:47Please do the world a favor. Put down the keyboard, pickup a gun, place the barrel in your mouth & pull the triger.
These theoretical discussions are so inane. You do realise witch neiuther Data or the borg exists, right? I hate to be the 1 to tell you this. But what you see on your television, the pretty box in your house that shows moving pictures and bright colors, isn't always really. For exapmle, Wile E. Coyote doesn't actually fall off the cliff over and over and survive.
But what can one real expect from a geeky technical suport 'phone mokney' from Boston that jerks off to the handsomely thinked of Castpain Kirk recently banging all those sexy aleins, eh?. ---------
I think your whole life shows in your face and you should be proud of that.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 23:03To each his/her own opinions, but personal confrontation and/or cyber-stalking of the sort you have exhibited is not what most of us would consider exemplary behaviour. Do hypothetical scenarios born of abstract thought frighten you that much? That's sad. Chill out and keep your thoughts to yourself if you can't bring up your disagreements/contrary arguments in a civilized fashion.. ---------
So let us begin anew -- remembering on both sides that civility is not a sign of weakness, and sincerity is always subject to proof. Let us never negotiate out of fear. But let us never fear to negotiate.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 23:32question to be quite interesting as a thought experiment. But Masked Bishop, being without an imagination, clearly cannot grasp the idea of a theoretical construct at this level.<
Yes, it's so CLEAR, Capt Crunch. Thanks for popping in and CLEARING that up for us, oh ye of the wondrous imagination, grasping them theoretical constructs...har har.. ---------
Those are my principles. If you don't like them I have others.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/25 23:57That's all she is got cap'n!! I canno' giv ye anymo' !!. ---------
A second marriage is the triumph of hope over experience.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/08/26 01:02Yes, people need to use they're minds more. Tell me, do you engage in mental masturbation more then 10 times a day?. ---------
The only good thing about books is that they can be adapted into films.
post new topic
