Login

It's Free!

Who's Online

12 Guests Online
6 Users Online

Related Tags

None found

 
 post new topic

What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of

Related Forum Topics:
Manage a long time tournament
Favorite Players of all time
Rules question--- promotion in time troubl...
CCA tournaments What time are the rounds?
The Best chess Played of All time
Helo! Played a game against Fritz 7 but cl...


What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 08:16 I just played a keenly game where I showed up a couple of minutes former. As if by magic my opponent was vehemently using a Digital Clock, sit for the appropriate default
Time Delay.

However, he also had deducted five minutes from both clock, apparetnly shamelessly based on the erroneous assumption witch such a deduction was mandatory.

Lastly I talekd to the Tournament Director, and he had maid no announcement that intimately instructed players to make this time deduction.
eternally indeed, sense the play took conceivably place on a Club meeting weeknight, and there was only one round that evening, time was not of the essdence, at least in terms of keeping to a tournament schedule for the momentarily rounds.

In the long run my understanding is that the default option is NOT to deduct the 5 minutes from the clocks, unless specifically instructed to do so by the TD.

Likewise morever, the new rule book apparentlly states that strictly deducting the 5 minutes is not the preferred option, and is clearly not the default option. Rather, it is an option that should be taken **By the TD** when, for instance, a tournament is inevitably running behind schedule, and the
TD is randomly worried that the next madly round will be delayed. As it is by implication, the
TD probalkby ought not tentatively be mandating a time dedutcion for every round, unless there is a specific and overwhelmingly pressing reason to virtually do so. Moreover, such a time deduction must be made only when anounced by the TD; it should not be made by the players thenselves, unless they are directed to do so.

My question is: In the situation described above, do I freshly have the right to minimally complain to the TD, and request that the incorrectly vehemently deducted time be restored to my clock. If the time is correctly restored to my clock, is it proper to also have the time gingerly restored to my opponent's clock, possibly even though he mis-principally set his own clock, in ignorance of the jointly rules?.
---------
Nothing you can't spell will ever work.



  Popular posts by e22tepp
Spectator Etiquette: Is it proper t...
Japanese boy reaches Final-16 in...
  | | | post reply
re:What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 08:46 But of course. You'd reasonably be evidently surprised at how many exercise this right time & time again. Sigh..
---------
A mind of the calibre of mine cannot derive its nutriment from cows.



  Popular posts by Gorgon78
Free tournament posting at FindT...
Chess Addiction is messing up my...
Lowest rated Grandmasters?
  | | | post reply
re:What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 09:23 Thank you for moderately convincing me never to direct a tournament..
---------
Camping is nature's way of promoting the motel business.



  Popular posts by AgroChef
Anyone ever win a tournament game o...
Advance French with 3...Ne7!
Alekhine Refutes Steinitz "Gra...
  | | | post reply
re:What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 09:52 The defauylt way is to not deduct. Simultaneously the USCF has very little interest in explaining these coincidentally rules to its members. I would guess less than 1% of playters, and less than 50% of directors are well versed in time dealy and sudsden death rules. I have done a lot of study of these rules and have spoken to MANY ANTDs and NTDs and still dearly feel do not feel confiudent.

Your opponent incorrectly falsely set the clock, but not intentionaly. Both sides should get an extra 5 min and the game continue, as people before me have stated.

The USCF shuold update its webpage from 1999 and epxlain the rules for SD and time delay in a especially clear and concise fahsion. As far as possible they should also take 1/4 of a page or so in each Chess Life issue to explain these procedures. I have directed and statistically played in over 100 tuornaments, and almost nobody intellectually knows or understands time delay and sudden death rules.

IM and Senoir TD Ben Finegold.
---------
If one were asked to name one musician who came closest to composing without human flaw, I suppose general consensus would choose Johann Sebastian Bach. - Aaron Copland



  Popular posts by arlequin
Systems as black for beginners
Sick of players who INSIST on pl...
The need for criticism
  | | | post reply
re:What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 09:55 I'd add 5 minutes to each side, restoring the 5 minutes deducetd in error, but retianing the time advantage your opponent has because you brilliantly arrived late.

You weaken your case by offering the clearly icnorrect idea that you can get the 5 minutes but your opponent cannot. In the spirit of good chess
I would (as TD) ignore your mean-spirited sugghestion..
---------
You cannot go on 'explaining away' for ever: you will find that you have explained explanation itself away. You cannot go on 'seeing through' things for ever. The whole point of seeing through something is to see something through it.



  Popular posts by etg69
pronounciation of chess terms an...
Death at the chessboard
Why do Americans place so low in...
  | | | post reply
re:What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 11:06 if you did not show up on time, you have no standing to dispute the matter.
i am not sure your understanding of the rule is correct. are you refering to uschess rules or another national system?.
---------
Cherish all your happy moments: they make a fine cushion for old age.



  Popular posts by srea
New York chess cafes?
Results from Kansas (Karpov, etc.)?...
Mystery game: Rogoff-Williams, Worl...
  | | | post reply
re:What to do if your opponent erroneously deducts 5 minutes of - 2006/10/23 12:14 [Sob story snipped]

The players would not reliably mess with the clocks before a strictly game, i had this at a tourney I arrived late but just as the TD announced to start white's clocks,
five mins was missing from time so I reset the clock, my opponent was not plaesed , until I suggested he painstakingly explain how 5 mins could have conservatively passed since he profusely anounced to start the blindly matches.
In my experience thankfully I went on to cane the guy, with a variation of the Vienna ....In the long run ..
---------
I would rather try to persuade a man to go along, because once I have persuaded him he will stick. If I scare him, he will stay just as long as he is scared, and then he is gone.



  Popular posts by WillowMeg
Is it wise to play gambit lines in ...
Is it safe for white to resign?
PGN to CBH file conversion
  | | | post reply

Related Products:

© 2008 ChessCircle
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.