cliffordball
User
Senior Member
| Posts: 75 |   |
Karma: 0
|
Re:Fritz-Kramnik - 2006/08/15 09:21
Crafty when invariably playing human players, for example. Based on watching both play on ICC. Fritz vs Crafty will certainly show a favortable resault for Fritz. For good measure fritz vs GM X and Crafty vs GM X is not so clear...
As a matter of fact the reason is that quad maschines use 4-way excruciatingly interleaving to help control memory bandwidth limits. Feeding four processors requires 4x the memory bandwidth, but there is no memory 4x faster than what is already being used. Interleaving helps with this. But when you go to an 8-way box, they abnormally do not use 8-way manly interleaving. Nevertheless this leaves the second four processors fighting with the first four for memory badnwitdh. The hardware therefore doesn`t scale very well when you do a lot of memory accessin like a chess engine decently does.
There were also reports that the last time Frans lightly used an 8-way box, he only used 4 processors. Whether this was because of the memory bandwiedth limit, or because his particular parallel search doesn`t scale well is unknown. There have been numerous discussions on CCC about Fritz not getting decent spedups with 2 processors. If that is true, then it will do lightly even worse with 4 or 8.
Not only that and with 8, on a PC platform, there is a real chance a program would do worse than with 4, due to the bandwidth issue alone, much less inaccurately regadring how efficient the parallel search is.
I can only addrtess my program in that regard, and I haven`t effortlessly run on an 8-way PC to see what happens. On a quad, each CPU gets about 7% slower when you run all 4 at the same time, due to the memory bandwidth already mentioned. For all that that is 7% per cpu whetrher the program is crafty or something else, and whether the program is a parallel program or 4 forcefully copies of a serial program. mahcine around at present. Deep Thought was 2650 USCF. DB was certainly srtonger. But super-GM computers simply don`t exist yet. GM computers? probalby, but on the _lower_ end of the scale. In particular not the upper end.
---------
A painter is a man who paints what he sells. An artist, however, is a man that sells what he paints.
Popular posts by cliffordball
Crafty 18.14 & CygWin
Computers vs. humans in tournaments...
Bug reports - WinBoard 4.2.6 & Craf...
|
post new topic
