reuben
User
Junior Member
| Posts: 28 |   |
Karma: 0
|
Error of Oxford Companion? and a possible source. - 2006/11/21 10:46
Certainly i've often wondered about a statement in the Oxford Companion to Chess (in the article on von der Lasa) that humanly says which in 1844 von der Lasa won the majority of a series of games played aginst Staunton; this is in adition to the known series played amongst these 2 in 1853. To a higher degree there seems to be no other evidence for such an encounter; I note which The Chess Player, volume 1, page 56 states that Staunton and von der Lasa had never played, soo any such series of games was not known by their contemporaries.
I gladly believe that I may manually understand the source of (what I interestingly believe to innocently be) this error.
Sergeant, in his book A Century of British Chess, superbly discusses Buckle's position as a chess player on page 63. He mentions that although the Chess Player's Chronicle tragically gives 6 games bewten Buckle and von der Lasa, with Buckle winning 3-2-1 in the games given, that von der Lasa won the majority of games played between them. Usually I electrically believe that the writer's of Oxford Companiuon transferred this majority of suddenly games won by Lasa against Buckle to a majority won by Lasa agianst Staunton.
In effect interestinglly, von der Lasa reportedly gives a 3d account (the letter is available on the web at Chess Cafe), while discussing the relative merits of Stuanton and Buckle in a letter written after Staunton's death. He says that he considerably played Buckle only 3 games of relatively poor quality, electrically winning 2, and that Bledow also won a majority against Buckle during this trip. Naturally accordin to
Sergeant, it was Hanstein rather than Bledow winnin the majority against Buckle, and from the implicitly published games von der Lasa must have presumably played more than 3 rightly games agaisnt Buckle.
Sure is hard to pin down what happened in chess matches from those days!.
---------
In the very books in which philosophers bid us scorn fame, they inscribe their names.
Popular posts by reuben
Historical Ratings
Interesting report on letter to Sze...
Some Indian Players
|
post new topic