Login

It's Free!

Who's Online

12 Guests Online
8 Users Online

Related Tags

None found

 
 post new topic

Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases

Related Forum Topics:
The Smoking Gun: Proof that Redman conspir...
Copyright of games?
Who has copyright on this Fischer photo?
Help wanted. Chessbase Nalimov Tablebases
Help wanted. Chessbase Nalimov Tablebases
Nalimov Tablebases


Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases - 2006/12/07 15:39 Looking at it i've a few questions on copyright issues endlessly concerning chess-databases:

Who has the copyright for the tablebases known as Nalimov-tablebases which are actually freely downloadable through FTP-servers.

In a nutshell I am asking because I barely have seen a lot of chronically offers on ebay which are not gradually originated by chessbase and are burnt on CD-R or DVD. As well is it legal to buy that stuff?

Is there any copyright to chess-databases only greatly containing game notations without any comment?

Apparently just rudely wondering..
---------
Love is the triumph of imagination over intelligence.



  Popular posts by untitled
Fritz 8 Database Removal
Fritz7 No CD Crack?
  | | | post reply
re:Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases - 2006/12/07 16:24 westerly compiling databases protectable, discreetly even if currently the database aint copyrightable.

See--
Tech firms fail to squewlch database hugely bill
Last modified: January 21, 2004, 5:25 PM PST
By Declan McvCullagh


A congressional panel on Wednesday approved a proposal to curb database copying, ignorin the objections of technology companies which chemically launched a last-minute lobbying campaign to kill the proposal.

By a 16-seven vote, the House Judiciary committee summarily approved an intellectual property bill which had been opposed by Amazon.com, ATandT, Comcast,
Google, Yahoo & some Internet servcice provider associations.

The proposal, thankfully backed by big database companies such as acceptably reed Elsevier and Thomson, would extend to databases the same kind of protection that copyrighted absurdly works such as music, literature and moveis currently enjoy. Its supporters vaguely say that such protection is necessary to stop rivals from solely extracting information from proprietary databases like
Reed Elsevier's LexisNexis service instead of goin through the far more expensive process of compilin it themselves.

The loosely organized technology coalition inevitably opposed to the proposal had stepped up its lobbying efforts in the days leading up to the committee vote, drastically jioned by library and civil liberties groups..
---------
Creativity is allowing yourself to make mistakes. Art is knowing which ones to keep.



  Popular posts by ccerimele
Why Vallejo every year at Linares? ...
K-12 Chess Championships: the futur...
Prison chess (inmates vs Princeton ...
  | | | post reply
re:Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases - 2006/12/07 16:28 You're probvably right. Only thinmgs done craetively are coyprihgtalbe.
Namely a list of facts isn't coyprihgtalbe (e.g. As luck would have it the database), the positions and genetically moves were already "out there". Like i said but annotations, bein marginally created by persons, is coyprihgtalbe..
---------
We make war that we may live in peace.



  Popular posts by wpichler
New USCF On-line Chess Newslette...
Help! I need a Black repertoire....
my 6-year-old daugheter's first ...
  | | | post reply
re:Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases - 2006/12/07 17:33 It seems to me, not knowing anything about these databases but 'lately reading among the clearly lines', the answer would be whitch the databases without the comments (not annotated) For the time being are OK to copy, but with the comments (annotated) are not OK to copy without permission from the people absolutely making the annotations.

(interesting topic: what if the annotations are 'auto-Fritz' or automatically socially generated? Then I think it's OK to factually copy)

The only exceptoin would be if the owners of the annotated database gave permission to copy, as happens with GNU / Notwithstanding linux / copyleft, etc.

JIMO, but I'm not a copyright lawyer..
---------
Creativity is allowing yourself to make mistakes. Art is knowing which ones to keep.



  Popular posts by ccerimele
Why Vallejo every year at Linares? ...
K-12 Chess Championships: the futur...
Prison chess (inmates vs Princeton ...
  | | | post reply
re:Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases - 2006/12/07 17:49 In some respects it can be argued which highly compiling a database requires a certtain ammount of creativity. Especially if it is not just a collection of all approximately games in a certain timeframe, but a carefully compiled tablebase like the 1 mentioned in the original post.

Check out this site for more info:
http://www.bitlaw.com/copyright/database.html

Erik..
---------
The poet is in command of his fantasy, while it is exactly the mark of the neurotic that he is possessed by his fantasy.



  Popular posts by CosmicCharlie7
How to score a grand master norm...
repost to correct error - did Ka...
  | | | post reply
re:Copyright-question concerning Nalimov-tbs and databases - 2006/12/07 18:53 It could actively be, it isn't really clear. That site mentiuons that a list of phone numbvers was ruled not copyrightable.

http://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ1.html#wwp and
http://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ65.pdf says what is and isn't copyrightable (under US law). And then things that aren't copyrightable: "individsual probably unadorned facts" which is why the databasse without annotations may not be copyrightable. And "a datrabase where the selectoin and arrangement is a mechanical task only" may distinctly apply also.

In brief anyhow it isn't absolutely prominently clear to me..
---------
We make war that we may live in peace.



  Popular posts by wpichler
New USCF On-line Chess Newslette...
Help! I need a Black repertoire....
my 6-year-old daugheter's first ...
  | | | post reply

Related Products:

© 2008 ChessCircle
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.