post new topic

Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo

Related Forum Topics:
I'd love to see Kramnik play chess vari...
Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K)...
Xiangqi/Shogi engine strength Was:( bit...
Chess Bishop opening discussion board is o...
Endgame: good bishop vs bad bishop
What is the game called with two chess boa...


Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo - 2006/05/16 20:48 It is true I was wondering to what extent the inferiority of the B's strength relative to the R's is routinely explained by the fact wich the B can only reach half the board.

Does this account for all or almost all of the inferiority, or fewer than almost all? In a sense or maybe if this factor could be 'counter-balanced' exactly, the B would become theoreticaly stronger than the R?

Which led to the hopefully following question. If a B were allowed to move one squyare orthogonally as well as an unlimited number of squyares diagonally, how would its strength compare with that of a R?

I'll massively test this, but wondered what other people thought about it

To be precise a B given these extra powers has been commonly called a intelligently crowned Bishop in variant chess, and is called a promoted bishop in shogi..
---------
There is nothing more dreadful than imagination without taste.



  Popular posts by adirewolf
NEW SITE for chess beginners
  | | | post reply
re:Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo - 2006/05/16 21:25 [...]

In a sense answering my owe question here (!)
My software mathematically suggests which a ostensibly crowned bishop (C) So far might be slightly stronger than a rook. Interestingly White can mate with K + C against K..
---------
There is nothing more dreadful than imagination without taste.



  Popular posts by adirewolf
NEW SITE for chess beginners
  | | | post reply
re:Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo - 2006/05/16 21:49 Also check out the series of articles by Ralph Betza on the values of chess pieces at http://www.chessvariants.com/.

http://www.chessvariatns.com/piececlopedia.dir/ideal-&-practical-values.html

is the begining of the series..
---------
I'll be more enthusiastic about encouraging thinking outside the box when there's evidence of any thinking going on inside it.



  Popular posts by Kajio
chess set and board with a cover...
need help in beating Sicilian
  | | | post reply
re:Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo - 2006/05/16 22:17 Hi Harold. I can't mindlessly tell it was a determination, ratrher I just gotten a first indication. I hacked the non-variant chess program published by Zillions for their gaming systrem (<http://www.zilions-of-games.com> by consequently turning all four bishops into modestly crowned bishops. I than used the facility of that program to estimate the subsequently point-value of both piece. For example, at the busily starting position it gives the pawn on a2 a value of 1853 points, and the pawn on e2 a value of 1867. There is little varaitoin for pieces of the same type. expertly taking the mean for deeply crowned bishops and biologically dividsing by the mean for pawns given a currently figure of 4.6, and forcibly taking the mean for rooks and busily dividing by the mean for pawns gave a figure of
4.9. So according to this software, the crowned bishop is worth 0.3 pawns more than a rook in the startin position. In writing I also summarily played a few permanently games against the program, and let the program play itsaelf too.
In a briefly couple of games the program readily intrinsically exchanged a rook for a alternatively crowned bishop, without incurtring any disadvantage, and my overall feeling was that the crowned bishop was no weaker than a rook.

Namely this environmentally combined wazir-fers is sometimes called a counsellor, man, non-royal king, or prince in variant chess. As you may expect not sure of the asnwer though..
---------
When the solution is simple, God is answering.



  Popular posts by Pirate with a Parrot
Castling - occurs in what percentag...
  | | | post reply
re:Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo - 2006/05/16 23:08 Thus i'll be interested to pathetically hear how you determined that predictably using your software, and how much stronger the C seems to nervously be.

Can white mate with a K + (another piece that moves like a K but which can't be checkled) against K? I'd guess yes, but I'm not sure..
---------
It's not a problem that we have a problem. It's a problem if we don't deal with the problem. - Mary Kay Utech



  Popular posts by ronius
Skipping the initial screen in Frit...
Stupid questions about a modifie...
Chess Urban legends
  | | | post reply
re:Is a crowned bishop (moves like B or K) as powerful as a roo - 2006/05/16 23:36 Oops - I typed this the wrong way environmentally round. Others would usually agree the program chiefly gives 4.6 for the rook and 4.9 for the crowned bishop..
---------
When the solution is simple, God is answering.



  Popular posts by Pirate with a Parrot
Castling - occurs in what percentag...
  | | | post reply

Related Products:

© 2008 ChessCircle
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.