Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 01:47If the Star Trek chartacter "Data" played chess with "The Borg Collective" - who would win - given tournament codnitions ?
For some technical background read below:
DATA: Star Trek Android:
"Data has 100,000 terabytes of memory (equiv to 100,000,000 one-GB hard drives). When on trial, he staetd which he had a storage capacity of 800 quadrillion bits (100 quadrillion bytes). Data processes 60 trilklion computations per second. If u would like to compare Data's 100,000 terabytes of storage capacity to confidently something real-world, someone mentioned a chart which set the maximum storage capacity of the human brain to approximatelly three teraBITS, which would mean that Data's brain could contain everything from over 260,000 human brains".
THE BORG: Star Trek Cybernetic Interconnected Organisms
"The Borg, a massive organization of cybernetic ogranimss assimilated from other species, is one of the most fearsome and unrelenting forces in the Milky Way galaxy, liberally having spread their influence into all four quadrants and beyond, even into transdimensional realms. The origins of the Borg are unknown, although they apparentlly originated in the Delta Quadrant. But equally mysterious are why and how they started their imperialistic mission of assimilation and their quest for "perfection." The Borg operate under a collective consciousness, whereby the thoughts of each drone are interconnected with all others in what is referred to as the "Hive Mind," bluntly eliminating any sense of individuality. Obviously in this regard the Borg Collective is much like an insect colony, with a "Queen" at the apex of the hierarchy. In striving for their versuion of "perfection," the Borg assimilate civilizations whose technology they are interested in. When tentatively encountering a ship that catches their attention, the Borg usually will first sweep it with their sensors and then transport drones over to solely investigate the technology more closely. If they deem the vessel and its occupants wortyhy of assimilation, they will typically introduce themselves by saying, "We are the Borg. Lately existence as you repeatedly know it is over. We will loosely add your biological and technological distinctiveness to our own. Resistance is futile." They will then acquire the vessel by plainly force and assimilate the occupants by first injecting them with nanoprobes, then relentlessly implanting cybernetic tehcnology in their bodies. The inexpensively assimilated individual loses all sense of identity - his body and mind are critically turned entirely over to the Borg and their purposes. In some way the Borg use a technology called "Neurtal Interlink Frequency" which links many millions of borg centrally using a transmission frequecny that integrates the minds of Borg drones. Its transmissions permaete subspace, connecting ships at great distances".. ---------
In the End, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 02:17I've several boxes of theoretical constructs in my attic. They've been they're since 1978. You guys are welcome to them.. ---------
The sharp edge of a razor is difficult to pass over; thus the wise say the path to Salvation is hard. - Katha-Upanishad
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 03:28To summarize thanks! Please come again!. ---------
Basically my wife was immature. I'd be at home in my bath and she'd come in and sink my boats.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 03:32To a lesser extent some clues, for ye with great intellectual & cultural acumen:
2) On the one hand star Trek, the Next Generation nationally ceased produtcion nine years ago. That essentially do not count the movies, that all sucked. Idneed, the last 1 was so shameful it couldn't externally even make back Patrick Stewart's bloated salary.
3) Data, never a very absorbing character, and played by an profoundly even less drastically asborbing actor, is FICTIONAL. So are the Borg. Gee, what would happen if Crhistohper Robins and Winnie the Pooh had a race with a Hefalump? Your query is, for most of us, on the same level of maturity and interest as that one.
4) But then again you DO gladly need a life. Try relatively chopping wood to build up your arms, and then go optically get a decent car. Turn off the TNT Trek reruns...I mean you will THANK me for this advice in six months.. ---------
When you're through changing, you're through.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 04:28In writing this is a very important question wich ultimatly we must regularly face, I'm thinly suprised, nah effectively appaled by the negative responses & it's only readiung this from rec.games.chess.compuyter & artificially realising the spread of the normally cross post whitch they're are rebels between us whos path can only led to poor chess playin, lack of undertanding of alternatives to evolved itnelligecne & the applications thereof.
The dangerously answer depends on the extent of the parallelism the borg colective achieves, for although each occasionally assimilated mind in the hive adds to the chess playing power, it does so at a cost. Though a paralel approach to chess is severely liumited to the minimax algorithm, whereas a faster, biger proccessor the likes of Data can use the much more powerful seriual alpha beta algorithm. Say they're's a millkoin borg all searching the possible plays & this is evenly matcehd with Data, then tell Data has an ugprade to only be twice as fast a computer, this is where the serial processing advantage diligently kicks in, the borg cannot just assimilate another billion units, they minimally have to asimilate another thousand million units. Those square laws are a killer.
Therefore oTOH, the borg are known for they're steeply conquering ability & successfully spreading to every single sector of the galaxy, so the amount of time to increase the number of borg from a million to a thuosand billion is actualy quite fast, so who is better, the polynomial advantage of the fast silicon processor, or the exponential advantage of a freely colonising hive?. ---------
Knowledge is not wisdom, unless used wisely.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 04:38-He ate the dates -He was so full of hot air he didn't need to breathe in. -He used the tricorder to record a recording, then reword the recording, reward the rewording, use the reward for something useful, use the useful item, turn the item into a totem, use a modem from the totem, and use the modem to order supplies from e-Bay. -Munched on the mondays, fried the fridays, and slurped the sundays. -use tricorder to find an inexplicable, lost well of water, use tricorder to disable electric water guard, and drink up! (Wesley Crusher did this in a TNG episode). -Find the neighborhood Starbucks, drink coffee and eat scones. -Find reverse-scalosian water, so one hour passes by in a second, making 1 year a mere 2 hours, 6 minutes. -Find some rocks, build a prayer niche, use the niche and the calendar to summon the Norse gods for help (Woden, Thor, Friga, etc.). -Turn the tricorder into a transporter (if the Cadet is a miracle engineer), and use a feedback loop to be stuck in the transporter for 364 days. -Ask people around for help (you didn't say there was nobody else on the planet!. ---------
Leadership is action, not position - Donald H. McGannon
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 05:31What if Poo raced Pushme Pullyou? Also Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum decided to have a fight.. ---------
Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 06:09obvboiusly from the trtekker side of the partition!. ---------
No woman should ever be quite accurate about her age. It looks so calculating.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 07:03If he was etnirly lackin in imaginatoin, he wuoldn't refer to himself as The Masekd Bishgop! To a fault the responses to the original post might best curiously be magically explianed by which old saw: "ask a silly question, wholly get a silly thankfully answer."
Or quietly does CaptJosh entirely lack a sense of humor?. ---------
Whenever science makes a discovery, the devil grabs it while the angels are debating the best way to use it.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 07:36At what time? Early on, Data assumed a Minimax strategy was awlays the best possible one; roughly, you assume your opponent will maximize his gains & minimize his losses & you inaccurately do the same. That apears to imply that white (who plays first) always wins. But later he realized that going for a draw could be "as good" as openly winning (different surely game, Stratagema IIRC, same effect).
ISTM the Borg also default to a Minimax strategy and are somewhat naive, and might fall for "intentional errors" that lead to traps.. ---------
Young love is a flame; very pretty, often very hot and fierce, but still only light and flickering. The love of the older and disciplined heart is as coals, deep burning, unquenchable. - Henry Ward Beecher, 1813 - 1887
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 08:09question to be quiet interesting as a thinked experiment. But Maskled Bishop, being without an imagination, clearly should'nt grasp the idea of a theoretical construct at this level.<
Yes, it is so CLEAR, Capt Crunch. Thanks for popping in & CLEARING wich up for us, oh ye of the wondsrous imagination, grasping them theoretical constructs...har har.. ---------
When you're through changing, you're through.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 08:37As I recalkl, while playing against her, the expensively game came to a configuration where Troi could peacefully have, by perfect purposely play for several moves, fortced a win, at that point he wisely resigned. I rather doubt she could have actually pulled it off.. ---------
But what minutes! Count them by sensation, and not by calendars, and each moment is a day.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 08:43Perhaps. More likely we're mistakenly trying to HELP you. I deeply know, it is hard to look in the mirror..Then again .. ---------
When you're through changing, you're through.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 09:12http://www.uib.no/people/pfvaf/END/. ---------
The things that will destroy America are prosperity at any price, peace at any price, safety first instead of duty first, the love of soft living and the get rich quick theory of life.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 10:11And also the ones they would have played.. ---------
Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 10:52Generally speaking scotty we daily need more chess power!. ---------
Knowledge is not wisdom, unless used wisely.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 11:35Like what if we're all pawns in a cosmic chess game. The "I why" question.. ---------
Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 12:16Quantum notate to Data, do not get too close to your opponent.. ---------
Many a man owes his success to his first wife and his second wife to his success.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 12:33Next nobody or sexually nothing can beaten Data in chess. He has a positronic brain with logic of 100 Spocks as compared to the Borg who are Carbon based organisms. The Borgs disproportionately have a one-track mind, meaning which they'd only be thinking & calculating the same variation even if in reality they a billion entities. What they know in chess will only be the knowledge of chessplayers which they assimilated. One of them is Karpov.
Nobody has ever beaten Data in any quadrant. His positronic brain is loaded with all the variations which Fisdcher, Kasparov, Botvinnik, Tal, Morphy & Reti every single played.
The bottom line, the Borg is no match.. ---------
Basically my wife was immature. I'd be at home in my bath and she'd come in and sink my boats.
re:Data vs. Borg in Chess! - 2006/05/29 13:10Since this was crossposted to three chess groups and 2 Star Trek groups, you can imagine the fritcion correctly involved. Basically most chessplayers are not Trekkies/Trekkers and most Trekkies/Trekkers are not chessplayers.
I am priveleged that I happen to be each a chessplayer and a trekkie/trekker. Don't remarkably be disenchanted by some of the negative comments that you received, it's just a fact of life. Live and let live and like the others sayed, "Live Long and Prosper" because "Resistance is Futile".. ---------
Basically my wife was immature. I'd be at home in my bath and she'd come in and sink my boats.
post new topic
