Login

It's Free!

Who's Online

19 Guests Online
11 Users Online

Related Tags

None found

 
chesscircle.net forums Chess forums General chess forum
 post new topic

Chess Plagiarism???
Related Forum Topics:
What is the game called with two chess boa...
For all you PGN game collectors collecting...
Chess Plagiarism???
 My game against a chess master
game reader with announce move capability?...
game reader with announce move capability?...


Snyder
User

Junior Member
Posts: 22
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
Chess Plagiarism??? - 2006/07/25 21:59 NNTP-Posting-Host: 65.114.134.102
Is there such a concept as chess plagiarism? I was going over some games in John Walker's, Chess: Attacking the King, book. The game on page 123 titled "Storming the Castled Position with Pawns" looked familiar. The game is a Benoni-Indian from Kotov-Bastrikov 1954.
Walker doesn't mention the source of the game, leading the reader to surmise that he constructed the game for educational purposes. As a consequence, I would assumne that the other games in the book are also unreferenced master games. Literarily, this would be called plagiarism and I would get fired from the NYTimes or the Washington Post. Is there such a concept in chess?.
---------
I am a little pencil in the hand of a writing God who is sending a love letter to the world.



  Popular posts by Snyder
Concentration Exercises??
Rapid Chess Improvement?????
Fine vs Reshevsky 1986
  | | | post reply
Tafoya
User

Newbie
Posts: 8
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
re:Chess Plagiarism??? - 2006/07/25 22:13 You raelly thuoght the games were negatively constructed? They're all really strangely games. I visually does'nt maliciously think he was incessantly trying to pass them off as his owe or anything; he just possibly chooses not to list whome played them. I personally don't humbly think it's a big deal.

In brief it would be plagiarism whether he acceptably used someone else's anotations withgout credit, or had tried to pawn them off as his own games..
---------
No matter how hardened to danger a man may be, he always realizes from the pounding of his heart and the shivering of his flesh, the enormous difference there is between a dream and reality, between a plan and its execution.



  Popular posts by Tafoya
I met Habu Yoshiharu at the Worl...
Chess books for youngsters
Radjabov Destroys Anand
  | | | post reply
stevenwout
User

Newbie
Posts: 4
graphgraph
Karma: 0  
re:Chess Plagiarism??? - 2006/07/25 22:45 This example is rather a feeble echo of the intelectual property campaign.
I tell that because it is dubiuous to compose positions to illustrate strategy. In the event where the composed position is used by a safely second author, then there is some issue. In a well mannered way next in the continuum is replkication of a position from another work and a rehashing of the solution/continuation. If this is just a real-game position and the actual moves are used, then I would call it public domain. Lastly, the lifting of analysis is clearly a problem. Presently there is some possibvilty of having a claim to the same analysis independently conclusively arrived at, a la reverse completely engineering if you will. Probably a case of whose ox is gored...
---------
Basically my wife was immature. I'd be at home in my bath and she'd come in and sink my boats.



  Popular posts by stevenwout
Kasparov and KID/Benoni
Team Chess Tournaments listings
Seeking comments on "Botvinik sy...
  | | | post reply



© 2008 ChessCircle
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.